Investigating and Developing the Desirable Model of Researcher Training in Islamic Science Centers with an Emphasis on Promoting Razavi Culture

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 PhD student in Educational Psychology, Department of Psychology, Bojnourd Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bojnourd, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Bojnourd Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bojnourd, Iran (Corresponding Author)

3 Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Bojnourd Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bojnourd, Iran

Abstract
Islamic science centers play an important role in the production, development, and promotion of Razavi sciences, culture, and education, and in line with their goals and missions, they use various models to supply, train, and empower Razavi scholars. Surveys show that the used models are not very comprehensive, up-to-date and effective. The main goal of this research is to investigate and evaluate the existing models and develop a desirable model for the training of researchers of Islamic sciences and Razavi teachings and the research question is how to determine the dimensions and components of the desired model of training researchers of Islamic sciences and Razavi sciences.
The current research is a type of applied research that is conducted using a qualitative method and is included in the group of phenomenological research. The data collection tools were semi-structured interviews and for data analysis, the theme analysis method and “Etrid-Sterling” model were used, the result of which was the identification of 4 overarching themes, 24 organizing themes and 228 basic themes with a frequency of 299 themes. . Consensus validity and structural strength were used to measure the validity of research variables. The results of the research showed that the ideal model of researcher training should have 4 dimensions of “fundamentals and approaches” with indicators of constructivism, objective orientation, interactionism, etc., “content” dimension with indicators; Valorism, modernism, skill-oriented, etc., then “management” with indicators; Need-oriented, conceptual map, knowledge management, etc. dimension “human resources” with indicators; motivation, promotion, etc., and to the extent that these dimensions and indicators are used in the researcher training process, research effectiveness will increase.

Keywords

Subjects


 Amirshahi, Mir Ahmad, Heydarzadeh, Kambiz and Dabastani, Fatemeh. (2011). The ‎Influence of Consumers' Innovativeness on their Shopping Decision Making Styles. ‎Modern Marketing Research, 1(3), 1-26. ‎‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Amirshahi, Mir Ahmad; Heydarzadeh, Kambiz; and Dabastani, Fatemeh. (2011). The ‎Effect of Consumer Modernity on Purchasing Decision-Making Styles. Modern ‎Marketing Research, 1(3), 1-26. ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎https://nmrj.ui.ac.ir/article_17610.html‎
Attride-Stirling, J. (2001). Thematic networks: an analytic tool for qualitative research. Qualitative research, 1(3), 385-405.
Bostan, Z., Yousefi, A., Shariati Mazinani, S. & Parsafjooh, S. (2018). The Meaning of ‎Blessing and the Methods of Sanctifying Objects among the Pilgrims of the Shrine of ‎Imam Reza (AS). Farhang Razavi, 11(44), 1-28. ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎ doi: 10.22034/farzv.2022.367077.1816‎
Burrell, Gibson, Morgan, Garrett. Macro-sociological Theories and Organization ‎Analysis: Sociological Elements of Organizational Life. Translator: Mohammad Taghi ‎Norouzi. Fifth Edition. Tehran: Samt Publications.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Corben, Henry; Corben, Henry; Ameli, Haider bin Ali; Yahya, Osman Ismail; and Yahya, ‎Osman Ismail. (2005-1426). Jame al-Asrar and Source of Anwar (Vol. 1-1). Beirut - ‎Lebanon: Arab History Foundation.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Danaee Fard, Hassan, & Kazemi, Seyed Hosein. (2010). Promoting Interpretive ‎Research In Organization: Overview Of Philosophical Foundations And ‎Conduction Process Of Phenomenography. Journal Of Management Studies ‎In Development & Evaluation, 20(61), 121-147. ‎[In Persian]‎ . ‎Https://sid.ir/paper/202839/en
Dashti, Roya, Asadi, Ismail and Zolfaghari Zafarani, Rashid. (2022). Introducing a Model ‎of Dark Sides of the Organization Based on the Theory of Social Interactionism in the ‎Higher Education System. Human Resources Studies, 12(1), 77-106. ‎[In Persian]‎
doi: ‎‎10.22034/jhrs.2022.150418‎
Doz, Y. L. & Hamel, G., (1998). Alliance advantage, Harvard Business School Press, Boston.
Eisner, E. W. (1994). The educational imagination: On the design and evaluation of school Programs. New York: Macmillan Publishing Company.
Faizi, Taherah; Omidi-Morad, Afsaneh; Garamipour, Masoud; Nazari, Maryam; and ‎Torkashvand, Zahra. (2016). Leveling the general and specialized abilities of ‎researchers in the country based on the RAAT test: a guide to improving research ‎training in higher education. Educational Leadership and Management, 37(10), 95-114. ‎‎[In Persian]‎ https://sanad.iau.ir/Journal/edu/Article/857413‎
Gagné, M., & Deci, E. L. (2005). Self-determination theory and work motivation. Journal of Organizational Behavior , 26(4), 331 -362.
Garavand H, Kareshki H, Ahanchian M. The Relationship between Self-efficacy in ‎Research and Research Performance A study on Students of Medical Sciences ‎University of Mashhad. Iranian Journal of Medical Education 2014; 14 (1) :41-51‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Gorji, Ebrahim, Barkhordari, Sajjad. (2009). Foundations of Research Method in Social ‎Sciences. Tehran: Sales Publications.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Ireland, R. D . & Hitt, M. A . & Vaidyanath, D. (2002) .“Alliance Management as source of Competitive Advantage” .Journal of Management. 28(3
Jouybari, Leila, Yousefipour, Mohaddeseh, and Sanagoo, Akram. (2012). Knowledge ‎translation and application of research, a strategy for increasing research performance ‎of medical students. Qualitative Research in Health Sciences, 1(1), 0-0. ‎[In Persian]‎. ‎https://sid.ir/paper/462641/fa
‎Kazemi-Moghaddam, Iman. (2016). Educational Textbook of Network Theory of ‎Problems. Mashhad: Institute for Strategic Studies of Islamic Sciences and Teachings.‎ [In Persian]‎ ‎
Motlabi, Dariush and Alipour Hafezi, Mehdi. (2023). A look at research on the subject ‎area of Imam Reza (AS): A scientometric study. Razavi Culture, 11(42), 83-122. ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Nouri, Ali. (2014). "The Expertise Model and Educational Criticism". Iranian ‎Encyclopedia of Curriculum. pp. 1-6.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Pintrich, Paul; Shank, Dale. (2017). Motivation in Education (Theory, Research and ‎Applications). Translator: Mahnaz Shahraei. Tehran. ghalam Publishing.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Rahmanzadeh, Mohammad. (2003). Process-oriented Organization and Organizational ‎Paradigms. Tehran: Society Study-Publication Office.‎   ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
‎Rahnamaei, Ahmad. (2001). Occidental Studies. Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and ‎Research Institute Publications.‎ [In Persian]‎ ‎
Rashad, Aliakbar. (2016). The Scientific-Educational System of Destiny Development. ‎Tehran: Publications Organization of the Research Institute of Islamic Culture and ‎Thought.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Rezayat, Gholamhossein; Gholizadeh, E. "The Competency Model of Faculty Members ‎of the Islamic Revolution University". Management at the Islamic University. Year 10. ‎Number 2. pp. 324-303.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎
Sadra, Alireza. (2006). Value-Based Research in Iranian Society. Tehran: Strategic ‎Research Center of the Expediency Council.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
‎Salehi et al. "What Do Students Research For?". 5th International Conference on ‎Graduate Development, Opportunities and Challenges. Ferdowsi University of ‎Mashhad.‎ [In Persian]‎ ‎
Tavakoli M, Yamani N, Javadi M. Comparing Educational, Research and Administrative ‎Activities of Faculty Members Completing their PhD Degree either using Scholarship ‎Funds or not. Iranian Journal of Medical Education 2010; 10 (3) :301-311‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎URL: http://ijme.mui.ac.ir/article-1-1430-fa.html
URL: http://ijme.mui.ac.ir/article-1-2928-fa.html
Vaezi, Ahmad; Abdollahi Nissiani, Ali; Ebrahimi, Karim. (2017). "Issue-centered and non-‎issue-centered; comparison and analysis of organizational orientation approaches in ‎the management of cultural organizations in the country". Religion and Cultural Politics. ‎Issue 9. pp. 7 - 32.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Wasiti, Abdul Hamid. (2013). Research Guide Adapted from the Islamic Perspective on ‎Science and Existence (Introductory Level) (Volume 1–1). Holy Mashhad - Iran: ‎Institute for Strategic Studies of Islamic Sciences and Education.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Wasti, Abdolhamid. (2010). A Guide to Education Adapted from Islam's Attitude to ‎Religion, Science and Religious World. Mashhad: Institute of Applied Studies in Islamic ‎Sciences and Teachings.‎ ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎
Yaghoubpour, Sima, and Fatemi Nejad, Mohammad. (2017). The relationship between ‎job satisfaction and employee motivation using Herzberg's two-factor model. A New ‎Approach to Educational Management, 8(1 (29th issue), 263-281. ‎[In Persian]‎ ‎https://sid.ir/paper/516426/fa